Let me start by saying I am not a fan of Robby Gordon. I don’t like him. I never have.
Although I didn’t see the race yesterday I think he has a point and, as usual, it appears NASCAR has once again failed to consistently follow their own rulebook. This is the same rulebook that they shoved into Robby Gordon’s face after the race.
Kevin Harvick held off hometown star Patrick Carpentier to win the inaugural Busch Series race in Canada on Saturday, but Robby Gordon defiantly tried to claim the victory in a controversial finish that thrilled the crowd and infuriated NASCAR.
Marcos Ambrose was headed toward what would have been his first NASCAR victory when Gordon passed him after a restart with four laps to go as several cars crashed behind them. Gordon was out front for mere seconds before Ambrose nudged him from behind to send him into a spin as Ambrose reclaimed the lead.
Gordon was stuck idling on the historic Circuit Gilles Villeneuve as the field roared by him under caution. When he recovered, he raced back to the front and gave Ambrose a retaliatory bump, then tried to move into the first position behind the pace car.
Gordon believed he was in first — and at worst, second — when the caution waved. But NASCAR said the spin left him unable to maintain his position and ordered him back to 13th.
Several cars crashed behind them as Gordon was passing Ambrose and the caution flag flew. At that point the field is locked, and Gordon was in first, or at worst, second. Several years ago NASCAR changed the rules pertaining to the caution flag. In an effort to make things a bit safer, and eliminate racing back to the flag, NASCAR’s own rulebook now says the field is locked in position, based on the scoring loops, when the caution flag waves.
According to every report I have read about the race, Robby Gordon was in first or second place when that caution flag came out. When he was spun out, he says NASCAR even told him to go back to second place for the restart, before changing their minds and attempting to send him back to 13th place.
“You always go back to your position if you get spun out, and [Ambrose] spun me under the caution,” Gordon said. “They told me originally to go back to second place, and I went back to second place. Then halfway around the last [caution] lap, they said to go back to 13th place or 14th place, something like that.
“I was never running 13th or 14th, so I don’t know what to say.”
Like I said, I didn’t see the race, but, if all of the reports I have read are true, then he’s right, and NASCAR once again failed to remain consistent while referencing the rule book.
To be honest, it sounds to me like they wanted a hometown guy, Carpentier, to win the inaugural race in Montreal, and they were willing to “bend” the rules once again to accomplish it. Too bad it didn’t work, huh?
Now, today, we find out that NASCAR has suspended Gordon from the Nextel Cup race at Pocono because he “flaunted several NASCAR rules and directives from officials” during the Busch race. Here is Gordon’s response:
“I want to start by expressing my regrets to the sponsors, fans, and all competitors for any part I played in the miscommunication, confusion and uncertainty surrounding the finish in this weekend’s Busch race in Montreal,” Gordon said in a statement posted on his Web site.
“It was not my purpose to disrespect the authority of NASCAR or the officials. I do respect their authority to run the race and make the calls, and I understand the significance of the black flag. I strongly disagree with the calls that affected me at the end of the race. Being spun under the yellow and not being allowed to resume my position prior to the spin put me in a position to react as I did. Nonetheless, I accept NASCAR’s decision and I intend to move forward under the rules.”
It sounds to me like he truly believed he won that race, and based on all accounts thus far, I think he may have indeed done so. Of course, there are two sides to every story, and here is NASCAR’s version of the events:
On Saturday, Ramsey Poston, NASCAR managing director, corporate communications, outlined the chain of events that led to Gordon’s penalty.
“Once the caution came out on Lap 72 the field was frozen. Once the field is frozen, all cars must maintain cautious pace in order to be scored.
“At the time that the field was frozen, the 59 [Marcos Ambrose] was in the lead. [Robby Gordon] did not maintain cautious pace and by NASCAR rule, cars not maintaining cautious pace are scored only when they blend back into the continuous line. [Gordon], based on our scoring, was ordered to blend back in behind [Ron Fellows] in front of [Mike Wallace].
“The tower ordered [Gordon] multiple times to get into position. The directive was acknowledged by [Gordon's] crew chief and the crew chief also communicated the order to [Gordon]. The driver ignored NASCAR’s directive.
“He was warned that he would be black-flagged if he did not comply. Once [Gordon] crossed the start/finish line he was posted per the NASCAR rule book and at that time the directive to display the black flag was given.
“After contact with [Ambrose] on Lap 73, NASCAR took emergency action per the rule book Section12-2, thus parking [Gordon], which was also ignored. The black flag with the white cross was displayed to [Gordon] when [he] crossed the start/finish line on Lap 74. [Gordon] finished the race in the 18th position.”
Normally, I cannot stand Robby Gordon, and I hardly ever agree with anything he does, or says. But with this one, I think NASCAR really screwed up.
Sphere: Related Content