The Canadian Red Cross pleaded guilty Monday to distributing blood tainted with HIV and hepatitis C in the 1980s, and was fined $4,000 in the public health disaster that infected thousands.
More than 1,000 Canadians contracted blood-borne HIV and up to 20,000 others were infected with hepatitis C after receiving the tainted blood products. About 3,000 people had died by 1997 and the death toll has grown, but recent estimates were not available.
“(The) Canadian Red Cross Society is deeply sorry for the injury and death … for the suffering caused to families and loved ones of those who were harmed,” said Dr. Pierre Duplessis, the secretary general of the Red Cross.
So… What gives? The Canadian Red Cross admits to infecting over 21,000 people with HIV and hepatitis C, yet they are only fined $4,000. That’s $5.25 per victim. Wow. Steep fine. You do know that “fines” are not awarded to the victims right?
In addition to the fine, the charity will set aside $1.2 million for scholarships for family members of those affected as well as a medical research project.
Scholarships are nice.. When they actually pay for something… If we use the 1997 death toll figure stated above, we know there are no more than 18,000 victims still alive, which amounts to $66.67 per person in scholarship money. That should cover some bus fare, paper and pens, right? Oh yeah, and what about that research project? Hmmm.
Federal prosecutor John Ayre said the fine was adequate given the Red Cross’s status as a humanitarian organization, noting it no longer engages in blood collection or distribution.
The Canadian Red Cross has already paid victims $55 million in a separate fund.
Whoa. I guess I should have read the entire article before I started quoting from it, eh? $55 million has already been paid to the victims. I apologize for making light of the $66.67 amount. Far be it from me to make light of the fact that they actually paid another $2,619.05 per person. Color me embarassed…
Although…
According to the Public Health Agency Of Canada,
Documented health costs due to hepatitis C are high and rising quickly. For example, treatment with the ribavirin/interferon alfa-2b combination can cost up to $30,000 per course of treatment for an infected person.
Of course, that figure does not even come close to the amount needed if the victim required a liver transplant.
There are only limited data on direct costs, but studies from other countries suggest that there may be costs associated with detecting the infection, managing and treating hepatitis, and managing associated or resulting conditions such as liver cancer and liver transplants, and, finally, providing terminal care.12
Indirect costs associated with hepatitis C represent productivity losses due to premature mortality, reduced work performance or absenteeism from work due to sickness or the effects of treatment, and missed days of work for family or friends who are providing care for the infected person. It is estimated that there will be added pressure on Canada’s social support systems because of hepatitis C; there are already indications that infected individuals are relying on permanent disability pensions as a source of primary income.
Personal costs may be significant as well; individuals report that hepatitis C results in a notable and negative effect on quality of life as a result of stigmatization and the physical symptoms of the disease.
So… The very generous Canadian Red Cross voluntarily awards each victim $2,619.05 (plus the $66.67) to help compensate for a treatment that will cost no less than $30,000 and a lifetime of other troubles. Forget me, color them embarassed. They knowingly distibuted tainted blood to thousands of victims and they think their “fine” was adequate? The money awarded to each victim pays for less than 9% of the total treatment and nothing towards the rest of their lives that were totally screwed because of someone’s illegal activity.
Oh, wait… That’s right… Their medication is subsidized, right?
Talk about a slap tickle on the wrist.
Sphere: Related Content